Gibbs Paradox and Entropy - Similarity

Three different kinds of entropy-similarity (or entropy-distinguishability) relationship: The resolution of this paradox has been very controversial. Some debates are reflected in the following references: The following items will be processed and added:

Lin SK
Similarity principle and rejection of Gibbs paradox.
ABSTR PAP AM CHEM S 218: 244-PHYS Part 2 AUG 22 1999

Lin SK
Understanding structural stability and process spontaneity based on the rejection of the Gibbs paradox of entropy of mixing
THEOCHEM-J MOL STRUC 398: 145-153 JUN 30 1997

Lin SK
Gibbs paradox of entropy of mixing: Experimental facts, its rejection and the theoretical consequences
ELECTRON J THEOR CH 1: 135-150 1996

Lin SK
Correlation of entropy with similarity and symmetry
J CHEM INF COMP SCI 36 (3): 367-376 MAY-JUN 1996

BLUMENFELD LA, GROSBERG AY
GIBBS PARADOX AND THE NOTION OF CONSTRUCTION IN THERMODYNAMICS AND STATISTIC PHYSICS
BIOFIZIKA+ 40 (3): 660-667 MAY-JUN 1995

GOODISON JW, TOMS DJ
THE CANONICAL PARTITION-FUNCTION FOR QUONS
PHYS LETT A 195 (1): 38-42 NOV 21 1994

BEGHIAN LE
MAXWELL DEMON REVISITED
NUOVO CIMENTO B 109 (6): 611-616 JUN 1994

WERNER RF
THE FREE QUON GAS SUFFERS GIBBS PARADOX
PHYS REV D 48 (6): 2929-2934 SEP 15 1993


PESIC PD
THE PRINCIPLE OF IDENTICALITY AND THE FOUNDATIONS OF QUANTUM-THEORY .1. THE GIBBS PARADOX
AM J PHYS 59 (11): 971-974 NOV 1991

WANTKE KD
A REMARK ON THE GIBBS-PARADOX OF THE ENTROPY OF MIXING OF IDEAL-GASES
BER BUNSEN PHYS CHEM 95 (4): 537-537 APR 1991

DENBIGH KG, REDHEAD MLG
GIBBS PARADOX AND NON-UNIFORM CONVERGENCE
SYNTHESE 81 (3): 283-313 DEC 1989

RICHARDSON IW
THE GIBBS PARADOX AND UNIDIRECTIONAL FLUXES
EUR BIOPHYS J BIOPHY 17 (5): 281-286 1989

ZARAISKII AP
SO-CALLED OPERATIONAL SOLUTION OF THE GIBBS PARADOX
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 63 (7): 1993-1994 JUL 1989

KHAITUN SD
ZARAISKII,A.P. COMMENTARY ON SO-CALLED OPERATIONAL SOLUTION OF THE GIBBS PARADOX
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 63 (7): 1994-1995 JUL 1989

MACDONALD JJ
GIBBS PARADOX - 2 VIEWS ON THE CORRECTION TERM
J CHEM EDUC 63 (8): 735-735 AUG 1986

KEMP HR
GIBBS PARADOX - 2 VIEWS ON THE CORRECTION TERM
J CHEM EDUC 63 (8): 736-736 AUG 1986

KEMP HR
GIBBS PARADOX FOR ENTROPY OF MIXING
J CHEM EDUC 62 (1): 47-49 1985

HOME D, SENGUPTA S
EXTENSIVITY OF ENTROPY AND MODERN FORM OF GIBBS PARADOX
PRAMANA 17 (6): 509-514 1981

LESK AM
ON THE GIBBS PARADOX - WHAT DOES INDISTINGUISHABILITY REALLY MEAN
J PHYS A-MATH GEN 13 (4): L111-L114 1980

LANDSBERG PT, TRANAH D
GIBBS PARADOX AND QUANTUM GASES
AM J PHYS 46 (3): 228-230 1978

SEMENCHENKO VK
GIBBS PARADOX, THERMODYNAMICS AND EQUATION OF STATE
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 51 (4): 956-958 1977

VARSHAVSKII YS, SHEININ AB
DISCUSSION OF GIBBS PARADOX
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 49 (2): 564-564 1975

CASPER BM, FREIER S
GIBBS-PARADOX PARADOX
AM J PHYS 4 (4): 509-511 1973

BAZAROV IP
GIBBS PARADOX AND ITS SOLUTION
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 46 (7): 1892-& 1972

LYUBOSHI.VL, PODGORET.MI
REPLY TO I P BAZAROVS GIBBS PARADOX AND ITS SOLUTION
ZH FIZ KHIM+ 46 (7): 1896-& 1972

LYUBOSHI.VL, PODGORET.MI
GIBBS PARADOX
SOV PHYS USPEKHI 14 (5): 662-& 1972

ALEXANIA.M
GIBBS PARADOX IN PARTICLE PHYSICS
B AM PHYS SOC 17 (1): 42-& 1972

ALEXANIA.M
GIBBS PARADOX IN PARTICLE PHYSICS
PHYS REV D 4 (8): 2432-& 1971

Search
http://xxx.lanl.gov

Some links

James Baugh, Gibbs' Paradox, http://www.maxwellian.demon.co.uk/art/lnG/Gibbs1.html
Shu-Kun Lin
, The Similarity Principle and Its Application, see Figure (c). http://www.mdpi.org/lin/similarity/similarity.htm
Eric H. Neilsen,
Maxwell's Demon and Gibbs's Paradox, http://users.ntsource.com/~neilsen/papers/demon/node6.html
D. J. Raymond,
http://www.physics.nmt.edu/~raymond/classes/ph13xbook/node234.html
Mark Tuckerman,
The Gibbs paradox
Eric W. Weisstein, Gibbs' Paradox, http://www.astro.virginia.edu/~eww6n/physics/GibbsParadox.html

Copyright: The copyright  fo all the pdf files belong to the original holders. I added the pdf files here for the conveninence of my own research only.

Comments are welcomed. Please write me (lin@mdpi.org) if you have a paper to be listed here.

Entropy (ISSN 1099-4300)
Compiled by Dr. Shu-Kun Lin
Last change: 5 April 2005